In a previous blog, I discussed the process of a parent obtaining a guardianship for their special needs child. This blog discusses why it is not a good idea to try to shortcut this process and to simply have your child sign a power of attorney. Unfortunately, I have heard practitioners suggest this approach, and frankly, it made me cringe as it would be committing legal malpractice to have most special needs children sign a power of attorney.
In order for a power of attorney to be considered legally valid, the person granting the power of attorney would have to fully comprehend the power of attorney, including the powers that it grants to others to act on their behalf. The reality is that the majority of special needs children would be unable to fully comprehend a power of attorney to the extent they are legally required to do so in order to be able grant such authority. While some special needs children may possess the necessary intellect and understanding to grant a power of attorney, most special needs children could not meet this burden. Despite this reality, I have seen practitioners have special needs children sign powers of attorneys when they were simply not competent to do so. Unfortunately, this can lead to future problems for both the parent and child as discussed below.
One potential problem could arise if an individual, who is a family member or any other party with a potential interest, seeks to challenge the power of attorney in court. Should such a challenge be levied, an evaluation would be performed as to legal capacity of the child to grant a power of attorney. Should the challenge prove successful it would result in the invalidation of the power of attorney, and further, can lead to the invalidation of other transactions wherein the power of attorney was utilized, as well as the assessment of counsel fees and sanctions against the parent who improperly obtained the power of attorney. This could lead to a disastrous result for both the child and his/her family. Another problem that could arise is that the power of attorney does not legally establish that the child is legally incapacitated. As such, in the absence of this finding by a court, which is always made during a guardianship proceeding, the child may be able to legally bind himself/herself to transactions that they undertook, or they may undertake other transactions contrary to their interest which may be difficult to unwind. On the contrary, once a legal guardianship is granted by a court and there is a finding of legally incapacity, the guardian would be able to quickly void any such transactions which may not be in the best interests of the child.
As such, for the reasons discussed above it is bad idea to attempt to utilize a power of attorney when a guardianship is more appropriate. Frankly, this blog simply touches the tip of the iceberg as to potential issues, however, it should be clear that a guardianship is vastly preferred for most special needs children. Obviously, parents who are interested in this process should consult with competent legal counsel to guide them through it.