Trader Joe’s Wins Summary Judgment in Heavy Metals Lawsuit

Food and Drug Law at Keller and Heckman

Email

202-434-4100

Bio and Articles

Find Your Next Job !

Marketing Manager
PLI Practising Law Institute

Health Law Attorney

Senior Vice President and Chief Legal Officer

Associate Attorney

Explore More Job Openings

Summary Judgment Granted in Heavy Metals in Chocolate Class Action

by: Food and Drug Law at Keller and Heckman of Keller and Heckman LLP - The Daily Intake

Friday, April 4, 2025

Print Mail Download info_icon_img

/>i

A district court judge has granted Trader Joe’s motion for summary judgment in a class action lawsuit alleging that the company’s dark chocolate bars contain the heavy metals lead, cadmium, and arsenic. In granting summary judgment, the court found that Trader Joe’s “did not have exclusive knowledge that the dark chocolate bars contained or had a material risk of containing heavy metals,” which is a requirement under the applicable state consumer protection laws.
In January 2023, Trader Joe’s was hit with 10 class action complaints claiming the company failed to disclose the presence of heavy metals in dark chocolate products. The complaints were consolidated in April 2023, and claims for violations of consumer protection laws in Washington, Illinois, and New York survived a motion to dismiss. Each of the claims under these state laws requires exclusive knowledge of omitted information and excludes claims if that omitted information was reasonably obtainable or easily discoverable by consumers.
Trader Joe’s presented articles from as early as 2002 reporting the presence of heavy metals in chocolate products. The judge rejected arguments that the information was not reasonably obtainable because the plaintiffs were not aware that the products contained heavy metals, stating that “[w]hether information on the presence of heavy metals in the products was reasonably obtainable (or easily discoverable) does not depend on what individual plaintiffs were or were not aware of . . . [but] turns on what information was reasonably obtainable or easily discoverable by consumers about the presence of heavy metals in dark chocolate.”
The judge did note, however, that if the plaintiffs had alleged that Trader Joe’s failed to disclose a specific amount of heavy metals, high levels of heavy metals, or that the levels exceeded some kind of regulatory threshold, then the information might not be reasonably obtained by consumers.
The presence of heavy metals in chocolate has been the subject of studies and lawsuits in recent years. Keller and Heckman will continue to monitor activity related to heavy metals in chocolate and other foods.