HB Ad Slot
HB Mobile Ad Slot
DoD Must Embrace Crowdsourced Data to Maintain Battlefield Edge
Monday, April 28, 2025

The Department of Defense stands at a critical crossroads in how it processes, authorizes, and utilizes data in operational environments. Despite living in an era of unprecedented information availability, our military continues to operate under outdated Cold War-era policies that treat virtually all operational data as "intelligence," triggering cumbersome oversight mechanisms and stifling battlefield innovation precisely when we need it most.

This legacy approach is fundamentally misaligned with today's reality. The modern battlefield isn't defined solely by classified systems and traditional intelligence collection—it's increasingly shaped by ubiquitous sensors, civilian smartphones, commercial satellite imagery, and crowdsourced insights. These non-traditional sources often provide commanders with superior situational awareness, delivered at greater speed and scale than our existing systems can match.

Yet when field units attempt to leverage these resources, they encounter a bureaucratic staffing nightmare. The requirement for Intelligence Community coordination under frameworks like ICD 304 creates unnecessary delays, even when the mission has nothing to do with intelligence collection. This procedural bottleneck doesn't just slow procurement—it fundamentally changes how commanders approach risk and innovation at the tactical edge.

Our adversaries face no such constraints. While DoD components navigate labyrinthine approval processes, peer competitors and non-state actors readily exploit publicly available information, commercial data streams, and crowdsourced platforms to enhance their operational picture. The irony is striking: information that's freely available to civilians worldwide requires special authorization before our warfighters can use it effectively.

Consider the practical applications we're missing: real-time weather conditions in denied environments, hyperlocal combat indicators tracked by civilian observers, pattern-of-life data from commercial sources, and social sentiment analysis that could provide early warning of destabilizing events. These capabilities aren't theoretical—they exist today, often with clear licensing frameworks and established data provenance that should make them immediately adoptable.

The solution requires policy courage, not technological breakthroughs. The Department must explicitly reclassify crowdsourced and commercial data as "operational data" when used outside traditional intelligence collection mandates. Non-intelligence operations should be exempted from ICD 304 coordination requirements when leveraging publicly available or properly licensed commercial information. Field units and combatant commands need department-wide guidance authorizing them to acquire and use these non-traditional data sources without unnecessary delay.

This isn't about circumventing proper oversight—it's about recognizing that not all data is created equal. When information is already in the public domain or commercially available through legitimate channels, the primary consideration should be its operational utility, not whether it satisfies intelligence collection frameworks designed for covert sources and methods.

The DoD must shift its cultural mindset from treating data primarily as a security liability to recognizing it as an operational advantage. This means prioritizing innovation and battlefield effectiveness over compliance with outdated procedural requirements. It means empowering commanders to make informed decisions using the best available information, regardless of its source.

The tools exist. The data exists. The demand from operators exists. What's missing is the policy framework that allows these elements to come together at the speed of relevance.

We face a simple choice: either the DoD adapts to the realities of the data age, or it cedes advantage to adversaries who already have. In an era where information superiority often determines battlefield outcomes, we cannot afford to be the last to recognize that the nature of data has fundamentally changed. The time for policy courage is now.

HTML Embed Code
HB Ad Slot
HB Ad Slot
HB Mobile Ad Slot
HB Ad Slot
HB Mobile Ad Slot
 
NLR Logo
We collaborate with the world's leading lawyers to deliver news tailored for you. Sign Up for any (or all) of our 25+ Newsletters.

 

Sign Up for any (or all) of our 25+ Newsletters