HB Ad Slot
HB Mobile Ad Slot
Part 2: Children and Location: Ferguson’s FTC Privacy Enforcement Priorities
Friday, May 16, 2025

While Andrew Ferguson advocates for a restrained regulatory approach at the FTC, his statements and voting record reveal clear priority areas where businesses can expect continued vigorous enforcement. Two areas stand out in particular: children’s privacy and location data. This is the second post in our series on what to expect from the FTC under Ferguson as chair.

Our previous post examined Ferguson’s broad regulatory philosophy centered on “Staying in Our Lane.” This post focuses specifically on the two areas where Ferguson has shown the strongest commitment to vigorous enforcement, explaining how these areas are exceptions to his generally cautious approach to extending FTC authority.

Prioritizing Children’s Privacy

Ferguson has demonstrated strong support for protecting children’s online privacy. In his January 2025 concurrence on COPPA Rule amendments, he supported the amendments as “the culmination of a bipartisan effort initiated when President Trump was last in office.” However, he also identified specific problems with the final rule, including:

  • Provisions that might inadvertently lock companies into existing third-party vendors, potentially harming competition;
  • A new requirement prohibiting indefinite data retention that could have unintended consequences, such as deleting childhood digital records that adults might value; and
  • Missed opportunities to clarify that the rule doesn’t obstruct the use of children’s personal information solely for age verification.

Ferguson’s enforcement record as commissioner reveals his belief that children’s privacy represents a “settled consensus” area where the commission should exercise its full enforcement authority. In the Cognosphere (Genshin Impact) settlement from January 2025, Ferguson made clear that COPPA violations alone were sufficient to justify his support for the case, writing that “these alleged violations of COPPA are severe enough to justify my voting to file the complaint and settlement even though I dissent from three of the remaining four counts.”

In his statement on the Social Media and Video Streaming Services Report from September 2024, Ferguson argued for empowering parents:

“Congress should empower parents to assert direct control over their children’s online activities and the personal data those activities generate… Parents should have the right to see what their children are sending and receiving on a service, as well as to prohibit their children from using it altogether.”

The FTC’s long history of COPPA enforcement across multiple administrations means businesses should expect continued aggressive action in this area under Ferguson. His statements suggest he sees children’s privacy as uniquely important, perhaps because children cannot meaningfully consent to data collection and because Congress has provided explicit statutory authority through COPPA, aligning with his preference for clear legislative mandates.

Location Data: A Clear Focus Area

Ferguson has shown particular concern about precise location data, which he views as inherently revealing of private details about people’s lives. In his December 2024 concurrence on the Mobilewalla case, he supported holding companies accountable for:

“The sale of precise location data linked to individuals without adequate consent or anonymization,” noting that “this type of data—records of a person’s precise physical locations—is inherently intrusive and revealing of people’s most private affairs.”

The FTC’s actions against location data companies signal that this will remain a priority enforcement area. Although Ferguson concurred in the complaints in the Mobilewalla case, he took a nuanced position. He supported charges related to selling precise location data without sufficient anonymization and without verifying consumer consent. However, he dissented from counts alleging unfair practices in categorizing consumers based on sensitive characteristics, arguing that “the FTC Act imposes consent requirements in certain circumstances. It does not limit how someone who lawfully acquired those data might choose to analyze those data.”

What This Means for Businesses

Companies should pay special attention to these two priority areas in their compliance efforts:

For Children’s Privacy:

  • Revisit COPPA compliance if your service may attract children
  • Review age verification mechanisms and parental consent processes
  • Implement data minimization practices for child users
  • Consider broader parental control features

For Location Data:

  • Implement clear consent mechanisms specifically for location tracking
  • Consider anonymization techniques for location information
  • Document processes for verifying consumer consent for location data
  • Be cautious about tying location data to individual identifiers
  • Implement and document reasonable retention periods for location data

While Ferguson may be more cautious about expanding the FTC’s regulatory reach in new directions, these established priority areas will likely see continued robust enforcement under his leadership. Companies should ensure their practices in these sensitive domains align with existing legal requirements.

Listen to this post

HTML Embed Code
HB Ad Slot
HB Ad Slot
HB Mobile Ad Slot

More from Bradley Arant Boult Cummings LLP

HB Ad Slot
HB Mobile Ad Slot
 
NLR Logo
We collaborate with the world's leading lawyers to deliver news tailored for you. Sign Up for any (or all) of our 25+ Newsletters.

 

Sign Up for any (or all) of our 25+ Newsletters